

Top 5%
Justin Metzel - First Commonwealth Mortgage
Senior Mortgage Loan Originator | NMLS# 2143447

Justin’s focus is making the home buying process easy, whether customers are looking for their first home or their forever home. Justin is well-versed in all loan types including FHA, Conventional, VA, USDA and Construction. His goal is to ...... Show More
Location & Business Hours
Business Hours
Wed
9 AM to 5 PM
Thu
9 AM to 5 PM(Open now)
Fri
9 AM to 5 PM
View All days
Search Reviews
Search
Write a Review
Overall Ratings
Filter by Date
Range
Filter by Rating
Reviews from Web
I had the pleasure of working with Justin during my home-buying process, and I cannot recommend him enough! From the very beginning, he helped make the process smooth, clear, and as stress-free as possible.Justin patiently walked me through...
read more
Reply from Justin Metzel
April 4th, 2025 06:51 PM
I'm delighted to hear that your home-buying process was smooth and stress-free. It was a pleasure assisting you, and I appreciate your recommendation. Your satisfaction and understanding are important to me, and I'm glad my support met your...
read more
Justin was excellent in every important aspect of the mortgage process; professionalism, timeliness, expertise, relationship building, coaching/teaching... His guidance made a potentially long, laborious process easy and stress free. I cannot...
read more
Reply from Justin Metzel
March 30th, 2025 06:17 PM
I'm thrilled to hear that you found every aspect of the mortgage process to be excellent. It was a pleasure guiding you and making the experience stress-free. Thank you for your kind words and for acknowledging my efforts in professionalism...
read more
Justin was an excellent loan officer, especially since I was very new to the process as a first time homebuyer. Communication from Justin was great and proactive. If he did not know the answer, he would get it for me in a timely manner. He...
read more
Reply from Justin Metzel
January 29th, 2025 03:43 PM
Hi Austin, I'm so glad you had a great experience with me! Your feedback means a lot and I'm thrilled to hear that I was able to effectively guide you through the loan process as a first time homebuyer. Ensuring that my clients understand the...
read more
Justin has the patience of Job and is a complete ray of sunshine. Let’s just say my loan was not so simple, yet he worked tirelessly through every phase with cheerful enthusiasm and creative problem-solving. I credit my successful loan closing...
read more
Justin's communication and professionalism were the best we've received from any bank or service provider, ever. He fully explained the processes and procedures and made the entire transaction painless.
Justin's communication and professionalism were the best we've received from any bank or service provider, ever. He fully explained the processes and procedures and made the entire transaction painless.
Reply from Justin Metzel - First Commonwealth ...
May 26th, 2026 05:44 PM
Thank you, for your kind words. I'm pleased that my communication and professionalism met your expectations and that I could make the transaction process easy for you. If there's anything else I can assist with, please feel free to reach out!...
read more
Justin was very responsive and very knowledgeable. He took time to answer all our questions in a manner that made things easy to understand. We felt taken care of throughout the whole process, and we would definitely work with Justin again.
Reply from Justin Metzel - First Commonwealth ...
May 26th, 2026 04:29 PM
Thank you, Jared, for sharing your experience. I'm pleased to hear that you felt supported and that I was able to answer your questions clearly. It's appreciated to know you would choose to work with me again.
Justin Metzel - First Commonwealth Mortgage has received a review with 5 star rating from Joey M
Reply from Owner
May 26th, 2026 04:29 PM
Thank you, Joey, for the great rating. I'm pleased to know you had a positive experience with First Commonwealth Mortgage.
What can I say about Justin and the fantastic service he was able to provide by always being one call away when I had questions in regards to paper work or closing of the house. He was always explaining paper work, forms, and the closing process...
read more
Reply from Justin Metzel - First Commonwealth ...
May 26th, 2026 04:30 PM
Joseph, I'm grateful for your feedback. It was important to me to be readily available and to explain each step of the paperwork and closing process. I'm pleased that I could help make your transaction and transition as smooth as possible....
read more
Justin is awesome! Communication was outstanding, professional, and streamline. I really felt comfortable with Justin in asking questions through the home buying process ; it made me want to join first common wealth for my banking. I highly...
read more
Reply from Justin Metzel - First Commonwealth ...
May 21st, 2026 01:37 PM
Thank you, Josey, for your positive feedback. I'm pleased to hear that you felt comfortable with my communication throughout the home buying process. Your recommendation and consideration of First Commonwealth for your banking needs are greatly...
read more
10 of 149
About
Justin’s focus is making the home buying process easy, whether customers are looking for their first home or their forever home. Justin is well-versed in all loan types including FHA, Conventional, VA, USDA and Construction. His goal is to build relationships with all his customers through high-quality service as he walks them through all the steps of the financing process. While not working, Justin enjoys spending time outdoors or being with family and friends. He holds a Finance degree from Youngstown State University.
Products & Services
Mortgage Loan Officer
FHA Home Loan
VA Home Loan
Construction Loan
Bridge Loans
Medical Professional Mortgages
Fixed Rate Mortgages
Adjustable Rate Mortgages
USDA Loans
Qualified Mortgage Pre-Approvals
Specialities
Conventional Financing
FHA Financing
VA Financing
USDA Financing
OHFA Down Payment assistance
Construction Financing
HELOC / HELOAN
Bridge Loans
View All
Search Rank ScoreLearn More →
627
/850
Search Rank Score
What is the Search Rank Score®?
Experience.com’s Search Rank Score measures a professional’s online search visibility across hundreds of key SEO attributes.
Memberships
- Mahoning Valley Young Professionals
- The Steak Club Foundation
Addresses and Serving Areas
Year Started
2021
Time Zone
Eastern Standard Time (EST)
Licenses
- NMLS# 2143447
Achievements
- Mortgage Bankers Associations - School of Mortgage Banking I
Hobbies
- Music
- Hiking
- Golfing
View All
Disclaimer
First Commonwealth Mortgage NMLS # 479240 | Individual NMLS # 2143447