Nick Totarella

Name: Nick Totarella
Address: 5885 Landerbrook Dr Ste 310, Mayfield Heights, Ohio, 44124
Telephone: +1-440-724-2021
Rating: 4.94

Branch Manager

4.94

(842)

LET’S GET YOU INTO YOUR DREAM HOME It’s simple to get started on your mortgage journey – whether you’re just looking to get pre-qualified or are ready to submit an application. Just click the button below or submit a contact form to speak w... Show More

Mortgage

Mortgage Loan Officer

Contact Info

(440) 724-2021

Mayfield Heights, OH

https://cfmtg.com/ntotarella/

Location & Business Hours

Business Hours

Wed

8 AM to 5 PM

Thu

8 AM to 5 PM

Fri

8 AM to 5 PM

View All days

Search Reviews

Write a Review

4.94

(842)

Filter by Date

Range

Filter by Rating

5 Star

97%

4 Star

3 Star

2 Star

1 Star

Nick is amazing, very helpfull through the full process, from start to finish! Great communication Thanks

Thank you

Reply from Nick Totarella

January 30th, 2026 07:46 PM

Thank you!

Nick was extremely helpful all hours any day of the week we needed him! He got us into a program which ended up not working out. He was able to quickly adjust everything a day before closing allowing us to close on time still. Highly recommend!...

Nick was an All-Star from the get-go! I toured a house that I didn’t even plan on buying, on a Sunday afternoon, and he got me pre-approved at 10 PM on Sunday! Throughout our entire relationship he worked nights and weekends to make sure that...

Nick walked us through all of the options we had before moving forward with our process, something other lender don't do. He then communicated everything clea and worked with me to make sure I understood wvery step of the process!

Reply from Nick Totarella

January 30th, 2026 07:46 PM

It's great to hear that you felt informed and supported throughout the process. Ensuring that all options are clearly presented and understood is a priority for me. I'm pleased that communication played a positive role in your experience. If...

Absolutely loved working with Nick! Was very helpful and checked in often. Always answered questions in a timely manner. We were in a different and somewhat difficult contract that he worked out professionally.

As a first time home buyer with a unique financial situation Nick Totarella personally helped us every step of the way. No matter what he made sure to be transparent and give the best recommendations to help my family out. We recommend him...

Nick was so helpful through the entire process! Start to finish and question I had he could answer clearly and concisely. He made the process quick and smooth. Couldn’t recommend anyone better!

Nick worked to help me get everything in order to buy a house. Communicated effectively and was very professional. Would definitely recommend to friends

Nick is absolutely fabulous. He always made sure to have all our questions answered and he was incredibly professional and well informed. He is also a math wiz, and was able to give pretty accurate calculations when discussing the terms and...