Experience.com
Nick Totarella's Cover Image
Nick Totarella - Branch Manager in Mayfield Heights, OH

Nick Totarella

ClaimedPro

Branch Manager

4.94
(699)
Company Logo
LET’S GET YOU INTO YOUR DREAM HOME It’s simple to get started on your mortgage journey – whether you’re just looking to get pre-qualified or are ready to submit an application. Just click the button below or submit a contact form to speak w...... Show More
Company Logo
Location & Business Hours
Business Hours
Wed
8 AM to 5 PM
Thu
8 AM to 5 PM
Fri
8 AM to 5 PM
Overall Ratings
4.94
(699)
Filter by Date
Range
Filter by Rating
Reviews from Web
  • 5.0
    Encompass
    A
    Abby J D
    Sagamore Hills, OH
    Posted on June 3rd, 2026 03:10 PM
    Very avaliable to answer questions, and helpful at understanding what all goes into the loan, also found a way to remove pmi even without 20% down, and got us first time home buyer perk of getting some money back in taxes on the interest we...
    read more
  • 5.0
    google
    K
    Keairra M
    Posted on June 1st, 2026 03:14 PM
    Nick Totarella has received a review with 5 star rating from Keairra M
  • 5.0
    google
    K
    Keairra M
    Posted on June 1st, 2026 03:14 PM
    Nick Totarella has received a review with 5 star rating from Keairra M
  • 5.0
    Encompass
    K
    Keairra M
    EASTLAKE, OH
    Posted on June 1st, 2026 03:14 PM
    ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Nick was professional, patient, and always available to answer my questions. He kept me informed throughout the entire process and made my first home purchase feel smooth and stress-free. Thanks to his hard work and dedication, I am officially...
    read more
  • 3.0
    Encompass
    M
    Michael L
    FAIRLAWN, OH
    Posted on May 28th, 2026 02:01 PM
    Never heard from Nick (that I can remember) until I inquired as to where the buyer's loan process was at 14 days before closing which was 44 days after acceptance .
  • 5.0
    Encompass
    M
    Melanie K
    Berea, OH
    Posted on May 28th, 2026 01:34 PM
    Nick and the entire team were very responsive and answered all questions throughout the process. We had kind of a bumpy road while buying/selling at the same time and Nick was very helpful in coming up with solutions to make sure closing on...
    read more
  • 5.0
    Encompass
    K
    Kyle Z
    FAIRLAWN, OH
    Posted on May 27th, 2026 02:56 PM
    Kind service
    Reply from Nick Totarella
    June 3rd, 2026 02:57 PM
    I really appreciate the feedback and am looking forward to working with you again.
  • 5.0
    Encompass
    K
    Kristine K
    Lagrange, OH
    Posted on May 25th, 2026 09:33 PM
    Thank you for all your help and communication during the sale process
    Reply from Nick Totarella
    June 2nd, 2026 06:39 PM
    Thank you for the 5-Star review. If you need anything, feel free to give us a call.
  • 5.0
    Encompass
    B
    Barbara L B
    Ravenna, OH
    Posted on May 24th, 2026 05:52 AM
    wonderful experience all around!!
    Reply from Nick Totarella
    June 1st, 2026 05:55 PM
    I enjoyed working with you. Thanks for the great feedback.
  • 5.0
    Encompass
    L
    Louie B
    Willowick, OH
    Posted on May 21st, 2026 03:06 PM
    Quick, clean, communicative!
    Reply from Nick Totarella
    May 28th, 2026 03:06 PM
    I really appreciate the feedback and am looking forward to working with you again.
  • 10 of 699
    About
    LET’S GET YOU INTO YOUR DREAM HOME It’s simple to get started on your mortgage journey – whether you’re just looking to get pre-qualified or are ready to submit an application. Just click the button below or submit a contact form to speak with one of our mortgage experts. We’re here to help!
    Products & Services
    Mortgage Loan Officer
    FHA Home Loan
    VA Home Loan
    Jumbo Home Loan
    Mortgage Refinance
    USDA Loans
    Non-QM
    DSCR Loans
    Self-Employed Mortgages
    Second Mortgages-Bank Statement
    618
    /850
    Search Rank Score
    What is the Search Rank Score®?
    Experience.com’s Search Rank Score measures a professional’s online search visibility across hundreds of key SEO attributes.
    Addresses and Serving Areas

    Year Started

    2017

    Time Zone

    Pacific Standard Time (PST)
    Licenses
    • 1723224
    Achievements
    • Scotsman Guide Top loan officer in Volume
    • Scotsman Guide Top loan officer in units
    Disclaimer
    © 2024 Cornerstone First Mortgage, LLC. All Rights Reserved. NMLS ID #173855 Equal Opportunity Lender.