Nick Totarella's Cover Image
Nick Totarella - Branch Manager in Mayfield Heights, OH

Nick Totarella

ClaimedPro

Branch Manager

Company Logo
LET’S GET YOU INTO YOUR DREAM HOME It’s simple to get started on your mortgage journey – whether you’re just looking to get pre-qualified or are ready to submit an application. Just click the button below or submit a contact form to speak w... Show More
Company Logo
Location & Business Hours
Business Hours
Sat
closed
Sun
closed
Mon
8 AM to 5 PM
View All days
Overall Ratings
Filter by Date
Range
Filter by Rating
5 Star
97%
4 Star
2%
3 Star
1%
2 Star
0%
1 Star
0%
Reviews from Web
  • Encompass
    P
    Paul R D
    Ravenna, OH
    Posted on May 15th, 2026 10:20 PM
    Nick was an absolute joy to work with!! He answered questions quickly and efficiently and took away any anxiety u had as a first time home buyer. His customer service skills and the way he handles his customers is excellent. I would 100% recommend...
    read more
    Reply from Nick Totarella
    May 25th, 2026 07:36 PM
    Thank you for the 5-Star review. If you need anything, feel free to give us a call.
  • Encompass
    J
    Joseph A K
    Cleveland, OH
    Posted on May 14th, 2026 03:44 PM
    Nick was always pleasant, professional, and thorough. Great communicator.
    Reply from Nick Totarella
    May 21st, 2026 03:44 PM
    I enjoyed working with you. Thanks for the great feedback.
  • Encompass
    B
    Brittani M T
    Bay Village, OH
    Posted on May 11th, 2026 02:53 PM
    Nick is extremely proactive about making sure you have all the information necessary for a smooth transaction. Any questions or concerns I ever had were answered quickly and thoroughly, with kindness. He helped us get out credit scores up a...
    read more
    Reply from Nick Totarella
    May 18th, 2026 02:54 PM
    It was great working with you. Thanks again for putting your trust in us.
  • Encompass
    M
    Mark B G
    Smithville, OH
    Posted on May 4th, 2026 03:16 PM
    Nick went above and beyond to meet our needs .
    Reply from Nick Totarella
    May 11th, 2026 03:16 PM
    Helping great customers like you is why I'm in this business. Thank you so much for your business and great feedback.
  • Encompass
    N
    Nathan A M
    BEREA, OH
    Posted on May 4th, 2026 03:15 PM
    1. Be clearer on your disclosure for large money movements 2. Be clear on insurance or Taxes 3. Be clear that you can't get a better rate then a bank. In truth you were the exact same.
    Reply from Nick Totarella
    May 11th, 2026 03:15 PM
    Thank you for your feedback. Please feel free to connect with us to help us improve our services.
  • Encompass
    J
    Jeremy A J
    Akron, OH
    Posted on May 2nd, 2026 12:48 PM
    They made it so easy for us to get the house we wanted
    Reply from Nick Totarella
    May 11th, 2026 12:07 PM
    I really appreciate the feedback and am looking forward to working with you again.
  • Encompass
    B
    Benjamin I D
    Cuyahoga Falls, OH
    Posted on April 30th, 2026 11:00 PM
    Everything was explained and made easy, especially for a first time buyer. My nightshift schedule was also accounted for and worked around.
    Reply from Nick Totarella
    May 8th, 2026 07:04 PM
    It was great working with you. Thanks again for putting your trust in us.
  • Encompass
    M
    Michelle P
    MENTOR, OH
    Posted on April 27th, 2026 03:08 PM
    Communication, effectiveness, transparency.
    Reply from Nick Totarella
    May 4th, 2026 03:09 PM
    It was great working with you. Thanks again for putting your trust in us.
  • Encompass
    C
    Catherine K
    Twinsburg, OH
    Posted on April 26th, 2026 12:36 PM
    Nick went above and beyond for me thank you Nick
    Reply from Nick Totarella
    May 4th, 2026 01:57 PM
    It was great working with you. Thanks again for putting your trust in us.
  • Encompass
    C
    Curtis M
    GREEN, OH
    Posted on April 21st, 2026 03:32 AM
    Nick and his entire team did amazing from start to finish highly recommend
    Reply from Nick Totarella
    April 28th, 2026 01:49 PM
    It was great working with you. Thanks again for putting your trust in us.
  • 161–170 of 842
    About
    LET’S GET YOU INTO YOUR DREAM HOME It’s simple to get started on your mortgage journey – whether you’re just looking to get pre-qualified or are ready to submit an application. Just click the button below or submit a contact form to speak with one of our mortgage experts. We’re here to help!
    Products & Services
    Mortgage Loan Officer
    FHA Home Loan
    VA Home Loan
    Jumbo Home Loan
    Mortgage Refinance
    USDA Loans
    Non-QM
    DSCR Loans
    Self-Employed Mortgages
    Second Mortgages-Bank Statement
    What is the Search Rank Score®?
    Experience.com’s Search Rank Score measures a professional’s online search visibility across hundreds of key SEO attributes.
    Addresses and Serving Areas

    Year Started

    2017

    Time Zone

    Pacific Standard Time (PST)
    Licenses
    • 1723224
    Achievements
    • Scotsman Guide Top loan officer in Volume
    • Scotsman Guide Top loan officer in units
    Disclaimer
    © 2024 Cornerstone First Mortgage, LLC. All Rights Reserved. NMLS ID #173855 Equal Opportunity Lender.