Experience Logo
Unclaimed
Neighborhood
Google

Get found as the Top Insurance Agent in Elkhorn, WI

Kailey Andrews Wagener in Elkhorn, WI

Kailey Andrews Wagener

4.57
(21)
Whether you're purchasing a car, buying a home, managing an investment property, starting a small business or leaving behind a legacy, our American Family Insurance agency is dedicated to inspiring and protecting your dreams. As your agent ...... Show More
Overall Ratings
4.57
(21)
Filter by Date
Range
Filter by Rating
Reviews from Web
  • 4.0
    google
    J
    Jeff R
    Posted on February 21st, 2026 12:00 AM
    Helped bring our monthly car insurance down and homeowners. Not a lot, but better than going up.
  • 5.0
    google
    K
    Kathy B
    Posted on December 7th, 2025 12:00 AM
    She was amazing. Very patient and walked me through whatever I needed to know.
  • 5.0
    google
    J
    Judi T
    Posted on November 14th, 2025 12:00 AM
    Kailey Andrews Wagener has received a review with 5 star rating from Judi Torrez
  • 5.0
    google
    A
    Ashlee S
    Posted on October 28th, 2025 12:00 AM
    Outstanding service every time! The staff is professional, and truly takes the time to help with any questions or changes. Highly recommend Kailey Wagener Agency for anyone looking for dependable insurance and great customer care.
  • 5.0
    google
    J
    John J
    Posted on October 28th, 2025 12:00 AM
    Was easy to make changes and contact my agent
  • 1.0
    google
    B
    Bob B
    Posted on October 28th, 2025 12:00 AM
    Charged me almost double for the same coverage elsewhere. Never ever considered to reevaluate my plans to try to save me money or get better coverage. Even after being a customer for more then 10 years. All and all a horrible company.
  • 5.0
    google
    G
    Gail R
    Posted on September 18th, 2025 12:00 AM
    Kailey is especially detailed, amazingly kind and professional. I took the step of revisiting all my policies with AMFAM agent Kailey assuring appropriate coverage and financial management. She is a breath of fresh air, excellent, extremely...
    read more
  • 5.0
    google
    K
    Katie B
    Posted on September 18th, 2025 12:00 AM
    Kailey is so quick to respond and is very attentive to detail! I also really appreciate that she takes the time to help me understand how each of my policies work/what they cover, and she answers my many questions about insurance in general!!...
    read more
  • 5.0
    google
    G
    Gracie K
    Posted on September 18th, 2025 12:00 AM
    Kailey is the most thoughtful agent I’ve ever met and she always goes above and beyond for her clients with their best interest in mind. She is knowledgeable about anything insurance related and a great agent overall. I’m so glad to have her...
    read more
  • 5.0
    google
    D
    Doug Y
    Posted on August 9th, 2025 12:00 AM
    Was treated well. Knowledgeable and helpful. I would recommend for your insurance needs.
  • 10 of 21
    About
    Whether you're purchasing a car, buying a home, managing an investment property, starting a small business or leaving behind a legacy, our American Family Insurance agency is dedicated to inspiring and protecting your dreams. As your agent in Elkhorn, we'll work with you to identify your individual needs, and suggest insurance coverage to protect the dreams you're working so hard for.
    Specialities
    Car
    Home
    Life
    Boat
    Business
    Umbrella
    99
    /850
    Search Rank Score
    What is the Search Rank Score®?
    Experience.com’s Search Rank Score measures a professional’s online search visibility across hundreds of key SEO attributes.
    FAQs
    Here are some Frequently Asked Questions about Kailey Andrews Wagener
    What organization is Kailey Andrews Wagener associated with?
    Kailey Andrews Wagener is associated with American Family Insurance.
    What is Kailey Andrews Wagener’s work email address?
    Kailey Andrews Wagener’s professional email address is k******1@a****.com. You can also email Kailey Andrews Wagener by clicking on the contact Kailey Andrews Wagener.
    Where is Kailey Andrews Wagener based out of?
    Kailey Andrews Wagener’s primary location is Elkhorn, WI.
    What is Kailey Andrews Wagener's phone number?
    Kailey Andrews Wagener's phone number is (262) 723-4370
    What are Kailey Andrews Wagener's areas of expertise?
    Kailey Andrews Wagener specializes in Car, Home, Life, Boat, Business, Umbrella.