Experience.com
Unclaimed
Neighborhood
Google

Get found as the Top Insurance Agent in Middletown, MD

C

Carrie Catherine Hightman

4.87
(15)
Carrie Catherine Hightman, licensed Insurance Broker with Producer # 3000200636, expertly guides clients in Middletown, Maryland, toward comprehensive coverage solutions. With a commitment to personalized service, Carrie offers insightful a...... Show More
Location & Business Hours
Business Hours
Tues
9 AM to 5 PM
Wed
9 AM to 5 PM
Thu
9 AM to 5 PM
Overall Ratings
4.87
(15)
Filter by Date
Range
Filter by Rating
Reviews from Web
  • 5.0
    google
    K
    Kenny U
    Posted on November 10th, 2025 12:00 AM
    Great experience insuring a new driver at Hightman Insurance. Carrie and Twanna are extremely knowledgeable, personable and professional. They guided us through each step in the process, had us prepared for MVA visits, knowing which documents...
    read more
  • 5.0
    google
    3
    3 S
    Posted on October 3rd, 2025 12:00 AM
    Personable, knowledgeable and responsive. Very impressed.
  • 5.0
    google
    M
    Michele H
    Posted on September 9th, 2025 12:00 AM
    Carrie and Twanna are such a great duo! They care about you as a person not just looking at it as a job. They are there answering questions, making adjustments, getting quotes in record time which is so helpful when looking to purchase a vehicle....
    read more
  • 5.0
    google
    E
    Esther L
    Posted on July 9th, 2025 12:00 AM
    Hightman Insurance saved our family thousands of dollars when we switched to Erie. They are punctual and I have never met a business that responds back to your email so quickly. Great people, great business highly recommended!
  • 5.0
    google
    L
    Lindsay W
    Posted on October 9th, 2023 12:00 AM
    This is by far the cheapest car insurance I’ve paid since I started driving 14 years ago! Carrie and her family are wonderful and very helpful when it comes to any issues or problems you may have! They have been nothing but pleasant to work...
    read more
  • 5.0
    google
    M
    Melissa L
    Posted on October 9th, 2023 12:00 AM
    We've been customers for years and recently had to have our car repaired after a deer hit, and the customer service was exceptional! Carrie and Twanna were very responsive and helpful in answering all of my questions. I highly recommend Hightman...
    read more
  • 5.0
    google
    J
    Josh P
    Posted on October 9th, 2023 12:00 AM
    The Hightman’s have been fantastic to work with, quick to answer questions, great at getting quotes back fast, and are friendly. I would highly recommend working with them.
  • 5.0
    google
    N
    Noah N
    Posted on October 9th, 2023 12:00 AM
    Erie Insurance and the Hightman insurance agency are amazing at the work they do!
  • 5.0
    google
    R
    Randomadventurer 1
    Posted on October 9th, 2023 12:00 AM
    I've partner with Hightman Insurance for years for both whole life and car insurance. I couldn't be happier with their quick responses, thorough explanations, and friendly advice! They provide extremely competitive rates. 10/10 highly recommend!...
    read more
  • 5.0
    google
    K
    Kimberly N
    Posted on October 9th, 2023 12:00 AM
    Awesome agents! Help is always there when you need it!
  • 10 of 15
    About
    Carrie Catherine Hightman, licensed Insurance Broker with Producer # 3000200636, expertly guides clients in Middletown, Maryland, toward comprehensive coverage solutions. With a commitment to personalized service, Carrie offers insightful advice to navigate the complexities of insurance. She is available Monday through Friday, from 9 AM to 5 PM, dedicated to securing your peace of mind.
    54
    /850
    Search Rank Score
    What is the Search Rank Score®?
    Experience.com’s Search Rank Score measures a professional’s online search visibility across hundreds of key SEO attributes.
    Licenses
    • Producer # 3000200636
    FAQs
    Here are some Frequently Asked Questions about Carrie Catherine Hightman
    What is Carrie Catherine Hightman’s work email address?
    Carrie Catherine Hightman’s professional email address is c****************s@g****.com. You can also email Carrie Catherine Hightman by clicking on the contact Carrie Catherine Hightman.
    Where is Carrie Catherine Hightman based out of?
    Carrie Catherine Hightman’s primary location is Middletown, MD.
    What is Carrie Catherine Hightman's phone number?
    Carrie Catherine Hightman's phone number is (301) 473-4764