Employer Spotlight

Recruit Gen Y Stars

You need new tools to attract the new breed of talent - Experience will help you build your team with Gen Y stars.


Ease of Use

Our management dashboard helps you easily post jobs, pinpoint targeted candidates and manage your talent pipeline.


All Needles, No Hay

Don't wait for the best candidates to come to your door - with Experience, you can proactively target top talent.


Build Your Experience

Experience is your most important asset - we're here to help you find that next opportunity.


Tell Your Story

You're so much more than just your resume. Showcase your Experience.


Connections Matter

Introductions are made easy when you have Experience -- connect with alumni, mentors and industry insiders.


Use eRecruiting by Experience on campus?
Find your school here.

Home  > Article

Ensuring the Runner-Up for Your Job Doesn't Hijack Your Authority

By Joann S. Lublin
Talent Zoo

The good news: You accepted a terrific job offer. The potential bad news: You must supervise the internal runner-up for your spot.

Amid a buoyant job market, the problem appears to be spreading. "Anyone who comes into a moderately senior position will probably encounter resistance and possibly resentment from the passed-over insider," says Richard Guha, a partner for a small brand consultancy in San Marino, Calif., who has run into the dicey dilemma twice. "A lot of people don't recognize it until it's too late," he notes.

How can you make sure the loser doesn't hijack your authority, give you wrong information or otherwise derail your effectiveness as an outside hire?

To avoid being sabotaged, you should come well informed about your selection. "Find out all you can about what was behind your being brought on board over the inside contender," says Sheryl Spanier, a New York leadership consultant. Ask your boss why he didn't pick that individual and how to best use her talents, she suggests.

It's equally important to discover whether upper management appeased the defeated employee with a raise. The gesture may make that person "feel newly empowered and less willing to cooperate," says Vince Thompson, an Internet business adviser and former AOL executive.

After an energy company wooed Mr. Guha to lead a key division, the industry novice belatedly learned he had been chosen over a staffer who was a long-time friend of the founder and board chairman. The vanquished official soon complained to the chairman that Mr. Guha would wreck the enterprise. "He thought he had the right answers and I was the wrong answer," Mr. Guha remembers. He believes the badmouthing hurt his effectiveness.

If a prior relationship allows a spurned contender to circumvent you, try to "get your boss's help in making sure that the employee is sent back to you," Ms. Spanier says. In Mr. Guha's case, the chairman refused to curb his chum's misbehavior.

So, a month after he arrived, Mr. Guha took matters into his own hands. He solicited business insights from the disgruntled official over dinner once a week. The man stopped whining to the chairman, his cooperation improved and the division flourished. Their weekly or monthly meals lasted a year. Mr. Guha now wishes he had inaugurated the dinners right away -- "before the resentment could build up."

An immediate, frank chat with the passed-over prospect about his disappointment and career goals can also defuse the sticky situation. Act empathetic without naively assuming you will become friends. In discussing the associate's definition of personal success, stress that you value his abilities but you are the boss, recommends Barb Bridendolph, president of Crenshaw Associates, a New York career-advisory boutique. "Otherwise, you set false expectations that this role can be shared."

During her initial nine weeks with a Pennsylvania management-consulting firm, a senior vice president lacked time for a heart-to-heart chat with Paul Forti, a middle manager and psychologist rebuffed for her job. Being ignored by the new boss exacerbated his pain at being passed over, he recalls.

Dr. Forti deliberately kept his distance, never volunteering information. When consulting clients inquired about the executive, he curtly replied: "She is senior to me. She is obviously competent." But he told work buddies that he doubted she was the right pick. "I didn't want her to succeed," says Dr. Forti, now a management psychologist in Morristown, N.J. "That really hurt us both." He found himself testy with private-practice patients, while the senior VP "was always a little on edge."

A fall on the ice broke the ice. Dr. Forti saw his supervisor tumble as she emerged from her car one snowy morning. He rushed outside to help. "I'd really like to get to know you," the grateful executive said. They ate lunch together that day for the first time. She explained how much she respected him and promised they would operate as equals, according to Dr. Forti. Afterward, "we worked well together," he says.

Things improved partly because the senior VP offered Dr. Forti first crack at plum client assignments and touted his expertise when they made new-business pitches. Finding attractive opportunities for a rejected but well respected insider to shine is a good idea, career coaches advise.

The approach transformed one newcomer's possible opponent into an ally. A former international director of a Los Angeles skin-care manufacturer says the concern hired her for the new post rather than elevate its experienced head of international marketing. Aware of her young colleague's talents, the recruit agreed to make the lieutenant responsible for all of Europe.

The new executive also persuaded her boss to send workers, customers and suppliers a letter describing the plans to expand the marketer's duties. As a result, the ex-international director notes, "I had somebody 100% dedicated to being successful rather than trying to find a way to sabotage me." is the online destination for both job seekers and employers in the communications industry. It's also a must for up-to-the minute content on industry trends, news, career guidance, or just to schmooze. Find a better life with Talent Zoo (

More Related Articles

Take the Mint
How Sexy is the Sexiest Man Alive if he turns heads in the other direction when he speaks? How well Supported is the Best Supporting Actress if the person handing her the Oscar can tell she had three martinis in the Bentley?

Getting Through
Although email and instant messaging are quickly becoming standard forms of office communication, the telephone still plays an important role in business. Just like a face-to-face meeting, telephone conversations are expected to and should follow certain rules of etiquette to help make the experience pleasant and productive for all those involved.

Job Search Strategies Like Playing Chess
Like strategy games? You job search is like a chess match. If you want to win, think it out, don't just don't wing it!

Google Web Search
Didn't see what you were looking for?
powered by Google
Copyright ©2015 Experience, Inc Privacy Policy Terms of Service